The Earliest Western Ideas about 
Arabs and Muslims

Katharine Scarfe Beckett 

Lecture summary

Largely due to medieval discussions of their place in a Christian world, the Arabs, Ismaelites and Saracens have throughout history exhibited a series of fascinating relationships with each other in the European literary imagination.  

While we now identify the original Islamic conquerors as Arabs, the same was not true during the early middle ages (6th to 12th centuries AD). Instead, at that time, the Muslims, known as Saracens, were identified with the Old Testament people of the Ismaelites -- who had already been known as Saracens in western Europe since the fourth century, long before Muhammad’s lifetime. This ancient, pre-Islamic character of the Saracens in western European thought has significant consequences for our understanding of early Christian-Muslim relations.

Imported Latin literature introduced this concept into educated English thinking and a variety of strange and hostile ideas developed as new information about Muslims continued to arrive and to be assimilated within older traditions. Some early ideas about Muslims even moved, unusually, from learned Latin writings into English translations many years before the Crusades inspired a vernacular tradition of Saracens on the Continent.

After the Norman Conquest in England, the tradition of the Saracens in both Latin and the vernacular continued to be propagated. Two early ideas in particular – that the Saracens worshipped Venus, and that they had deliberately concealed their true identity – continued to find support into the fifteenth and even the seventeenth century. This has interesting implications for Edward Said's (and others') ideas about English perceptions of Islam.


 

<<RIIFS Home Page

<<Guest Speakers